Hehe i dont forget my vote but i forgot Mattafex vote lol hehe

I would like to nominate xzisted's 2nd Borderlands banner:

to replace #7:

Reason being is there is 13 fallout themed banners (not including screenshot contest winners and mod banners) currently in rotation 1/5 of them and I think #7 is the most basic of them. Also, this is a really good banner.

I like the 7 but if i have to choose which one is better then i go with the borderlands banner. so from me a YEAH! i also want to nominate the witcher3 banner from AdvancedTerror. its a very good one and we dont got a single one from this game.

also i asked in a few post before, if we should set the amount of rotating banners to 5 more. cause the decission which one should be replaced is very hard.

I vote YES to replace 7 with xzisted's Borderlands banner.

For AdvancedTerror's Witcher banner I vote YES but until we come to an agreement on increasing the number of banners in rotation, I would suggest replacing 44 with it.
44 is a nice clean banner but perhaps a bit too simple. The font is nice but other than that is is just a woman's face on a plain black background.

I agree with Cruz, as we replace more banners the decisions are becoming more difficult.

I did the Mad Max one:

for reference:

I was really surprised no one else had made one. I'm working on another at the moment  but there are a lot of good promotional shots out there so others should put their designs forward.

I agree with DVAted 44 is an excellent banner, and is very aesthetically pleasing. It represents the game and character very well. Its Elizabeth from Bioshock 4; more specifically the DLC Burial at Sea (great DLC btw). That DLC has a very strong, sexy noir vibe and the banner nails that in a simple way. So I'd vote no to replacing it. I vote for replacing no. 46 with my Witcher 3 Banner.

I also think that adding 5 more banners would be a good idea, there are a lot of good banners being made. The 5 that DVAted suggested are excellent and I'd vote for them.

I would say lets put them all in. 60 banner to rotate. And then lets make a break with banners. And perhaps focus on other things like mod banners hehe or GUN wallpapers.

I'm in agreement, I think 60 banners is a nice round number to stop at for now. As said before, now that we're getting to the higher quality banners to put into rotation the decisions are becoming much more difficult.
Also with the great improvements that @OakshieldDream has made I would not be opposed to her joining the GFX Specialist team.

Cruz brings up a good point about the Mod banners. We haven't reached 10 in the rotation yet but there have been many banners created thus far. Are we still waiting approval from the mod authors?

As the number of banners we recieve rise from day to day, we should make a brake. I will make a list with all new posted banners from thelast few weeks, to have a better overview. So we can pic out the best 10 banners to fill in the 60. i will start the list on saturday. What do you think?

That sounds like a good idea to me. I know that with my recent absence I'm sure I have missed out on seeing some great banner submissions.
Also having all the banners posted together allows for better comparison between them so it would make choosing a favorite a little easier.

Sounds like a good idea @Cruz011, would help with the flow of things.

as promised here is my choice from the last weeks. if i forgott some banner then please let me know i will add them to the list.

So many good banners to choose from but only 10 spots open, this has definitely become more difficult.
It took a bit of time and careful consideration but I have managed to narrow down the selection of recent entries to 10 banners that I think would be excellent additions to the current rotation.
The following banners are listed in numerical order, not preference.

My picks:
#5
#6 (after a resize to 900x200)
#8
#10
#11
#13
#17
#18
#20
#22 (after a resize to 900x200)

Again this was a tough decision, all the banners were fantastic and I'd choose them all if I could.

Concerning the 24 banners above, the 10 banners I choose are numbers 1, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 14, 16, 17, and 18.

Spoiler:

I'd vote yes for both of these too, that Witcher banner is cool.

Awesome work @Cruz011 this makes the whole process a lot easier.

My selections are:

#1
#2
#6
#8
#10
#14
#16
#17
#18
#22

These banners are all really good, to choose just ten was difficult, these are the ten that just stand out a bit more.

I vote YES for @xzisted's "Passion Never Dies" mod banner.

Banner:

I also vote YES on @xzisted's banner, however it needs a tiny fix. Underneath the image where the mod description and author is located the background should be transparent.

My bad, here I made it transparent.

Spoiler: