Gaming Underground Network

Come for the mods, stay for the community
 
HomePortalLatest imagesInterviewsRegisterLog in
Search
 
 

Display results as :
 

 


Rechercher Advanced Search
Info Panel
______________
MOD MASTER THREADS:
FALLOUT
THE ELDER SCROLLS

______________


______________


GUNinsider
Fallout Miami: Mika999
Stay Connected

GUNetwork
Keywords
money commonwealth hunk Mask ghost body vault khan suit ghoul NPCs boomers Gear Reforged dead Metal riot Duty power leon Superpele Ryse space boom marvel clone
Latest topics
» OICW Mod for New Vegas
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby DavidW75 Tue 22 Oct 2024, 19:37

» Looking for Gta 5 xbox one modded account
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby salman0786 Tue 08 Oct 2024, 11:47

» [FNV] Flickering Landscape Textures
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby zliu313 Fri 04 Oct 2024, 09:33

» Best Site Ever!
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby WasteNinja88 Sun 29 Sep 2024, 00:38

» Weird bug or glitch with Console Command. [FNV]
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby nickenicole47 Tue 24 Sep 2024, 14:11

» Suggestions on npc mod that Blends with dragbodys mod?
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby ilovebees.com Sun 22 Sep 2024, 01:31

» [FNV] Right Mouse Button Zoom/ADS Bug
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby Lankychazz2009 Sat 21 Sep 2024, 23:20

» (FO4) FO76 BOS Objects
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby campesino.p Sat 21 Sep 2024, 16:53

» [FNV] Dragbody's FO4 Power Armors bug.
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby Lankychazz2009 Thu 19 Sep 2024, 09:34

» Fallout: New Vegas "Pizza Boy" Mod
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby MrMistyEyed2 Mon 09 Sep 2024, 20:15

» Here Are Some Of The Best Mods From GunNetwork
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby Abyssfer Sun 08 Sep 2024, 05:02

» Saying hi after two years
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby spiralsandspirals Wed 28 Aug 2024, 19:39

» Looking for an alternative to Nexus
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby freakoverse Fri 23 Aug 2024, 05:50

» fallout 4 mods
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby salientguitar4 Mon 19 Aug 2024, 12:47

» [FNV] How to troubleshot infinite loading issues?
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby Abyssfer Wed 14 Aug 2024, 12:28

» Fnv Enable player control command
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby GenJohnWilliam Mon 05 Aug 2024, 16:25

» Problem with Dragbodies NCR overhaul
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby Lankychazz2009 Fri 02 Aug 2024, 15:53

» NCR Trooper Overhaul Armors with NCR Ultimate Overhaul
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby Abyssfer Thu 01 Aug 2024, 15:29

» Roland Deschain ist The Mysterious Stranger and other t
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby SpaceRanger Mon 22 Jul 2024, 05:15

» Guns you want in Fallout
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Emptyby SpaceRanger Mon 22 Jul 2024, 04:25

November 2024
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930 
CalendarCalendar
_
November 2024
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930 
CalendarCalendar

Share
 

 Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
AuthorMessage
noodles1976

noodles1976

Posts : 447
Join date : 2014-07-24
Age : 48
Location : South Carolina

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 12:02

Hello all,

I've been tinkering around with mods created by other authors for years now. I've always felt that customizing mods to suit my tastes for personal use has always been the way to go. It has helped me learn about how mods are created, to use the various editing tools (GECK/CK), and use Nifskope to a limited degree.

I was just curious to see how many of you follow this same approach, or if you prefer to make requests or suggestions of mod authors to make the changes for you.

Let's discuss it!

Cheers,

N~dles

_________________
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? New_si11
“Ignorance is curable, stupid is forever.” - Robert A. Heinlein
Back to top Go down
AlphaCenturion09

AlphaCenturion09

Posts : 201
Join date : 2014-04-21
Age : 27
Location : The United States of America

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 12:42

I started out like you and tinkered with other mods created by people and learned the same stuff as you. Nowadays I just make my own mods from scratch while still tinkering with other mods to suit my tastes.

_________________
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? IDgxVDC

My Achievements:
Back to top Go down
xtheoutcastedx

xtheoutcastedx

Posts : 210
Join date : 2014-07-26
Age : 29
Location : New Jersey, USA

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 12:54

If it's a minor change I'll do it myself. Of it's massive change using scripting or dialogue I will request for it to be done. I'm not really "fielded" in the GECK so for big changes I can't really do it myself.

_________________
Batman bouncing BorderlandsGroup VaultBoy
Back to top Go down
Scorpio9

Scorpio9

Posts : 232
Join date : 2014-07-30
Age : 35
Location : Croatia

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 13:02

Most of times I like mods as author created them, and now most of mods are supported by MCM, sometimes I do minor changes, only once have I requested a feature and that was to enable snow in whole wasteland instead rain in wasteland and snow in Jacobstown, I did try to do it my self but I failed.
Back to top Go down
noodles1976

noodles1976

Posts : 447
Join date : 2014-07-24
Age : 48
Location : South Carolina

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 13:24

I agree with you guys about mods that use complex scripts, however using this tutorial: http://www.cipscis.com/fallout/tutorials/beginners.aspx helped me immensely with making changes to them. Everything I edit is on a small scale (like changing activation keys on FOSE or NVSE mods without MCM compatibility), as to not completely unhinge and bork my install.

N~dles

_________________
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? New_si11
“Ignorance is curable, stupid is forever.” - Robert A. Heinlein
Back to top Go down
ArgusMercenary

ArgusMercenary

Posts : 250
Join date : 2014-02-24

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 13:33

I usually just change things myself. I don't like asking other people to change small things just because I don't like it. Aside from that some mod authors aren't all that friendly to make those sort of requests anyway.

Scripting is scripting, its not simple, but people can learn. Though if someone does learn, they should also learn how to make organized scripts, a lot of people just write whatever they want regardless of how messy it can get. Messy scripts are probably the cause of a lot of CTDs. It is just not about writing stuff, you have to think about its structure.
Back to top Go down
angelgu323

angelgu323

Posts : 233
Join date : 2014-07-27
Age : 29
Location : California

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 20:23

I'm a helpless baby when it comes to editing mods.
Granted I'm sure I can learn if I put in time, however school and sports drain me and as it is I already spend an hour aday installing and uninstalling mods
Fortunately most mods fit my taste so im happy Very Happy

_________________
"Now go! Let the Legend come back to life!"
—  Revolver Ocelot
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? CaesarLegionSymbol-1
Back to top Go down
PXN

PXN

Posts : 120
Join date : 2014-07-08
Age : 36

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 20:42

I edit as needed. bunsaki does all his mods for female only so i enable them for males when I play. its a pain when he updates the esp haha

_________________
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? 200
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest
avatar


Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyFri 01 Aug 2014, 20:45

As a modder, I have thoughts about this.

On one hand I'm totally fine if people edit stuff I release, for their own tastes and their own game.  When I release my ME mod, for example, someone might decide to make the M8 Avenger super overpowered and fire explosive peanuts.  That's their prerogative and wouldn't bother me in the slightest.

On the other hand... I do have a serious problem with people who make tiny changes to a significant or popular mod and then release it with their name on it.  That frustrates me immensely.

For instance lets say I make 'Mass Effect Weapons Pack by Tesvixen' which contains ports of all ME guns, authentic sounds, icons and careful balancing.  I spent weeks working on it.

Someone downloads it, takes an hour or so and edits the stats a little to suit their tastes, then re-uploads it as "Mass Effect Weapons Pack REBALANCED by ModStealingJerk".  

It isn't until you read their Readme's Credits section that you see that I'm actually the chick who ported the weapons/sounds etc to begin with.  And on top of that, they've named 'their' mod in a way that suggests it is somehow better or an improvement over my own.  That stuff annoyed me before I even modded myself, and now that I do mod, it straight-up pisses me off.
Back to top Go down
noodles1976

noodles1976

Posts : 447
Join date : 2014-07-24
Age : 48
Location : South Carolina

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptySat 02 Aug 2014, 01:18

@ Tesvixen - I'm no stranger to having my work 'appropriated' by others, and redistributed under different authorship. Many years ago, I was a fairly prominent texture artist for a game called IL2, I went by the screen name of Casey1976. A bunch of us like-minded 'skinners' (as we liked to call ourselves) created our own website and shared our templates, skins and tutorials based on our experiences with creating these pieces of 'art' with that community. Here's a sample of one of my skins...
P-38 NMF:
The 3D models that game used were essentially flat, featureless slabs...no normal maps, no bump mapping, we're talking very primitive stuff in the early 2000s. So, all the highs and lows, weathering etc is built as a 'fake 3D' effect in Photoshop on individual layers...some of my templates grew to be as large as 80 MB with 600 - 700 layers total. We're talking weeks, if not months of work to create all that detail from a set of line drawings.

Now, we had similar 'rules' about our content to what VGU has here...ask for permission, give credit and never ever claim ownership of something that is not yours. If you don't follow the rules, we'll skin you alive  Wink  .

Needless to say, my stuff got stolen by several people over the 7 years I was involved with IL2...I finally got pissed and I quit the community for good (at least my templates got pulled...the skins are up at the website still. One of my buddies talked me out of nuking everything).

This is EXACTLY why I don't redistribute, or ask to re-up somebody else's work that I've edited...it stays on my hard drive and will only be used by me. I know exactly what it is like to have somebody else take credit for something I spent weeks or months working on....and it's the most abhorrent thing in the world IMO.

Okay...that was a cathartic rant! I feel better now.

Back on topic!

N~dles

_________________
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? New_si11
“Ignorance is curable, stupid is forever.” - Robert A. Heinlein
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest
avatar


Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptySat 02 Aug 2014, 02:06

Ugh that sucks Noodles. Sad

About 10 years ago my ex-husband and a friend of his did a big Predator/Alien mod for Morrowind, and a lot of the meshes/textures in it were created by my ex, from scratch.

To this day, there are people who use those meshes in their own mods, never asking or contacting him. It doesn't get under his skin like it used to (has been a decade, after all) but it still chafes his butt a little.

Back on topic, if there was something about a mod I didn't care for or thought I could improve, I'd probably do it myself, rather than than contact someone and say 'hey great mod but I don't like this, could you fix it k thx'.

I'd never upload that change/fix though.
Back to top Go down
Scorpio9

Scorpio9

Posts : 232
Join date : 2014-07-30
Age : 35
Location : Croatia

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptySat 02 Aug 2014, 03:44

If mod author Alpha created a good mod but than someone (Beta) saw even greater potential of that mod and did some adjustments, it would be cool if beta asked Alpha to add his tweaks to the optional downloads of original mod, this would only benefit to the community. But if Beta uploaded whole Alphas mod with that additions like "rebalanced" or "reworked", that only shows low respect to original author (Alpha) + mod page must gain popularity from start, and Alphas is already popular (has endorsements or whatever).

There is also one more thing players don't like to download hundreds of different mods and than combine them to make one mod work, that is why Apple was successful, you plug it in and it works, ismple as that.
Back to top Go down
ArgusMercenary

ArgusMercenary

Posts : 250
Join date : 2014-02-24

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptySat 02 Aug 2014, 22:15

You know, I'm sort of doing that with someone else's mod, with their permission of course. I'm updating it but some would say it is also being improved. I'm rewriting the entire mod, because it was just unmanageable the way it was. Part of the reason it is so broken is because of that. I can understand why someone would say "improved" or "rebalanced". Maybe they don't even say it intentionally, I was going to call this mod "insert name here" "remade" and not because I thought myself better than the original author and even if I did, how could I say that without being a hypocrite, I mean I did stand on his shoulders (and many others) to learn what I learned.

This thread has actually given me ideas about how I will go about this once I'm finished working on this mod. I never intended to name myself as a co author or any of that non-sense, always thought the only author should be the original author. Now however, I'm not sure what I'll call the mod, once it gets released, but it certainly won't be "remade"
Back to top Go down
noodles1976

noodles1976

Posts : 447
Join date : 2014-07-24
Age : 48
Location : South Carolina

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptySun 03 Aug 2014, 13:18

@ ArgusMercenary - Well, your situation brings up an interesting issue...if an existing mod has become 'broken' or outdated by official patches, DLCs or advances in the script extender or lack of support in popular UI mods (MCM)...and permission is given...then why isn't it okay for you to take authorship of the work you're putting into it? It's not like you're just editing a line of script, adding a blue texture and calling it your own. If you're rebuilding it from scratch to be compatible with current installs...why not call it your own, with a 'based on' caveat in the title/description referencing the original work.

I don't see a problem with that...what Tesvixen was referring to was more of a blatant act of 'changed an armor color, made the gun do 5 billion points of damage and now it's my mod' type of stuff...not a thoughtful and considerate rebuild of a non-functional mod, like what you're working on. I don't know what your project is, but I'd support you in your endeavors just based on what you wrote above.

Good luck on the mod...hope to see it soon!

N~dles

_________________
Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? New_si11
“Ignorance is curable, stupid is forever.” - Robert A. Heinlein
Back to top Go down
ArgusMercenary

ArgusMercenary

Posts : 250
Join date : 2014-02-24

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptySun 03 Aug 2014, 16:28

You could say that, still I'm not the "owner" of the idea. The original author did come up with it, and did a lot as well. I feel he still deserves most of the credit. Even if it is remaking everything, I still changed his stuff because I thought mine did things better. Thankfully, the author was okay with it, which was one of my worries. Hopefully I can finish it up soon, I'm almost done with the hardest part.

Still don't want to make the title sound like something pretentious or "superior" though, so I'll have to check for titles.
Back to top Go down
Scorpio9

Scorpio9

Posts : 232
Join date : 2014-07-30
Age : 35
Location : Croatia

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptySun 03 Aug 2014, 17:10

@ ArgusMercenary - It's so nice to hear that you and original author found agreement regarding mod that is I'm presuming outdated or even potentially game breaking. Basically you are resurrecting, making 2014 version of old mod, bringing it back to community so everyone can enjoy it, and that is the way to progress.

My previous post was very general... There is to many variations of mods in terms of how complex they are, and same applies to changes that can be done on those mods.
Back to top Go down
andythefreezer

andythefreezer

Posts : 31
Join date : 2014-07-30

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? EmptyMon 04 Aug 2014, 18:41

that depends on the mod. I'm a noob with scripts, but for the most part the changes I want to make are simple geck stuff. But I'm not working on re-creating a "better" version of a mod, I'm just changing stuff so I'll enjoy playing the original mod more.
I only request fixes or updates.
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content




Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?   Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing? Empty

Back to top Go down
 

Requesting changes to mods, or proactive editing?

View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

 Similar topics

-
» Requesting Mods From VGUNetwork On The Vault Projects:
» TTW GECK NPC inventory editing
» Need help editing clothing meshes
» Issue with editing .esp files
» [FNV] GECK crashes when editing weapon.

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Gaming Underground Network :: Fallout :: Discussion-