If I understood correctly that the mod itself has russian subtitles and the mod author has not changed them, you can't change that with settings, you would have to modify the mod itself. The language setting only affects the vanilla game and DLCs, not mods. Because if someone has made a mod using the GECK with a different language, everything in that mod will be in his language unless he changes it manually.
The mod author has probably only changed the voice to english but not the subtitles. The only way to get english subtitles in his mod is to manually edit his mod and replace the russian text with english text.
You might even sometimes have it happen with mods that vanilla location names turn into a different language because of a mod. It's because of the same thing.
I hope this helps and is at least somewhat comprehensible, I might not be the best at explaining this in a clear way.
_________________
A secret message to the chosen ones:- Spoiler:
011010000111010001110100011100000111001100111010001011110010111101110111011101110111011100101
110011110010110111101110101011101000111010101100010011001010010111001100011011011110110110100
101111011101110110000101110100011000110110100000111111011101100011110101100100010100010111011
10011010001110111001110010101011101100111010110000110001101010001