Who do you think will win? I personally think Vader would win because of his brute strength and powers in the force.

Though I think it'll be kind of close because Maul is faster and more agile than Vader so that gives maul an Advantage.

I think it would be a good fight. But same I think Vader would because of his strength and his abilities

That would be an epic battle without a doubt. When it comes to it I believe that Vader would win. Vader just emanates that sense of brute force and power. secondly he has endured so much whether its from the removal of his limbs to getting his skin seared on Mustafar. He is by all means a human tank.

Judging from the movies only, Maul would win, but if you include everything in the extended universe I think Vader got this. In the original trilogy, the fights were slow compared to Darth Maul's battle in Phantom Menace. But I also think that Anakin Skywalker especially in the third movie version can beat Maul.

Maul would stomp Vader. Vader is strong but stiff. Maul is just so nimble. But im biased lol hes my favorite Sith.

AFAIK, Darth Maul has superior combat prowess, but he has limited Force powers, Vader in the other hand, is very talented in both fighting and the force. So I guess, Vader can maul Maul's butt. (hehehehehe)

Cpt.Rex wrote:

Vader.. thats simple. vader is a sith lord and maul only a aprentice. maul is a quick and agile fighter but he is not strong with the force. vader on the other side is strong in the force and he is a deadly and experienced fighter and he uses his life support suit to his advantege. remember that suit can even withstand a hit by a lightsaber ( luke vs vader in empire strikes back ). and forget "that he cant move fast"... he can move fast too if its neccessary. if not he would not be the feared jedi hunter he is known for. and i doubt he only hunted younglings after the empire was build.

I agree. After the purge vader sought out many powerful jedi that survived. The Arc troopers that never returned after their missions were a clear indication on who survived and who did not. So he went out hunting. Their is also that big fight on kessle were that handful of jedi jumped him. Also when you play him in tfu they gave an accurate depiction on his strength, remember he is the chosen one.

the emp beat both maul and opress at the same time,, powers in the force seem to be the winning factor in those types of fights so i gotta say vader would win in a heart beat.

even know i like maul much better

Yeah. This would be a cool fight to see. It'll be awesome, but I still think Vader will win.

That wold be an awesome fight but I feel like Vader could just use his force choke on him or just cut him in half like Obi Wan Kenobi did but cooler because it's a sith battle so I feel like Darth Vader would win.

Darth Vader may be an extremely powerful force user, but his saber ability and control lack the finesse of Maul, and far less then Kenobi, simply put he would be helpless in a straight up duel. Maul on the other hand lacks range, so it would be entirely possible for Vader to simply strangle, throw or smash him against objects. Experience is also a defining factor to this fight, as Vader (at least in the later part of the Galactic Civil War) had dueled, and defeated, numerous Jedi many of whom held much higher degrees of combat ability then Maul. However, if this duel were to be done at the beginning of Vader's reign (say, immediately after his transformation) his abilities would be gravely untapped, giving Maul a much greater chance at survival. (Sha Koon, limited as she was in the fight, was able to wound Darth Vader having no prior encounters with Sith or rouge Jedi.) So, less long winded terms (sorry) it depends on the amount of experience Vader has at this point, how many resources are available (troopers and reinforcements and the like) how many people on each side (which is debatable, as Maul was still in command of a small group of Mandalorians at this time) and if IF the emperor knows what's up, as this is a usual cop-out to keep Vader alive.

In Star Wars Tales 9: Resurrection you get to see them fight, and it's one of the cooler Star Wars comics I've read. Plus, the ending is fantastic, both badass and showing the emotions that drive a Sith. I definitely recommend reading it.

As much as i love Maul i think Vader would Destroy him in a 1v1 fight

I believe darth maul would win in a 1v1 against Vader, although vader is the stronger, more experienced sith lord I believe mauls physical abilities like his speed and agility give him an edge against vader.

Vader. Maul is fast yes, but Vader is far more powerful and connected with the force. Plus, unlike Maul, Vader is a Sith Lord and former Jedi Master. Maul was still an apprentice when he was taken out.
Maul is a fantastic fighter, but Vader is a fantastic fighter, pilot and sith master. So he wins. Plus extra points for killing Obi Wan and the Emperor.

This is from an actual Star Wars comic. Just wanted to point out that we don't need to ask this question.

A comic that is no longer canon, mind you.

Doesn't hurt to discuss the idea, in any case. One EU writer's version of that fight is hardly the definitive way it would or could go down.

Both of Vadar's masters rekt Maul. Vadar became more powerful than both--eventually. My vote is for Vadar.

Tesvixen wrote:

A comic that is no longer canon, mind you.

Doesn't hurt to discuss the idea, in any case.  One EU writer's version of that fight is hardly the definitive way it would or could go down.

God, don't remind me about the Sacking of The Expanded Universe...