This would be a hard question for me , but I think The Fallout New Vegas is the Best .
So , what I want from you is fill it with

a)Argument
b)When it would be "graphics" post a screenshot maybe , when" humor " quote some great text from game etc.

All I wan't from U is don't be a dick , just . Do not post critical comments like "New Vegas is life , The third is a hot s**t" etc. Trust me , you won't get liked here for that . (I wrote for you Newbies (BTW . I am the one of newbies )

That's a tough one, I really like New Vegas a lot because So many more mods on it and it has a good story line, but i like all the DLC in Fallout 3 and the map of it in general. I like how your walking in a destroyed town and going through subways. So for me fallout 3 is my favorite. If someone wants to covert any awesome star wars mod into fallout 3 (specifically clones and mandalorians replacement) I would be one super happy camper

That's a hard choice as I think Fallout had a better story and atmosphere but new vegas was better for mods and gameplay was much better plus there are some really goofy parts of the game especially with the wild wasteland trait, I'll put a example of the humor "but the girl is sick. With classic symptoms of, uh... Vagina Dentata?". So I have to say I prefer fallout new vegas for its changes and added humor.

I prefer Fallout 3 in just about every regard. Characters, setting, atmosphere/story... the only things I like better about New Vegas are the companions (which are incredibly well done) and the baked-in mods like upgradeable weapons/iron sights.

I play Fallout New Vegas because it's more recent. But I think Fallout 3 is better, as well of the dlc in Fallout 3.

I like Fallout 3 more honestly. It had a certain wow factor to me when it first came out. No offense, but New Vegas almost seems like a Fallout 3 mod to me.

Fallout 3 for sure. And i agree with person above me for New Vegas, when it first came out i had a felling that it's just some expansion map. But fallout 3 is harder to mod, and all good mods are now for New Vegas, so for vanilla game i would go with Fallout 3, and for modded game i would go with New Vegas.

Fallout 3 just has better atmosfere, big dark buildings, town ruins, creepy metro tunnels, and also a large part of map with waste and some small cities, while New Vegas is pretty much 2 main roads with cities around them and everything other is desert

Gedor wrote:

while New Vegas is pretty much 2 main roads with cities around them and everything other is desert

I do agree with this, there should have been way more little grocery stores and services, phone booths and in general more stuff near Vegas and in the suburbs.

I mean, it was 2077. You'd think the houses near Vegas would look more similar to the Sierra Madre villas, no one even has a swimming pool, which literally everyone above middle-class has in the US.

Fallout 3 i like the urban aspect with metro's, large buildings and the creature, characters, allies and all around enemies

I love them both but in my opinion Fallout 3 has a better story because it`s a lot more personal. You get to know the character and what drives him and you want to uncover what happened (i`m not going to write any spoilers just in case someone hasn`t played the game). I like the world in Fallout 3 a lot more because you can see all the devastation the bombing brought and there isn`t a lot of empty space like in New Vegas. On the other hand New Vegas has gameplay and overall improvements in every part of the game but the story isn`t as strong and most importantly you can not continue playing the game once the main quest is finished, for me that is the worst part of New Vegas. The map is bad there is a lot of empty space that is wasted e.g. a huge empty field with a ruined shack in the middle that you can not enter... All in all Fallout 3 is my favorite but New Vegas is definitely worth at least one playthrough.

Fallout 3's atmosphere was incredible compared to New Vegas... However, as much as I love Fallout 3, New Vegas's story was so much more detailed than Fallout 3. I mean yes, you escape the vault and search for Dad. But it just seems so rushed.

With New Vegas, I felt my choices really mattered and that was the game changer for me